EP04 Buying Fine Jewelry: Part 1 Diamonds

Click to Listen

Have you ever wanted to buy a diamond or another piece of fine jewelry but felt you should already know what you’re doing before walking into the store? This episode is for you.

I sit down with Nicole Nettles, owner of Blue Water Jewelers, and Kashmir Elkin, an engagement ring specialist, to talk through the questions people actually have before making a significant jewelry purchase. We’re keeping it practical: no gemology degree required.

We cover lab-grown vs. natural diamonds, what really affects sparkle, why cut matters, how carat weight can be misleading, what to know about resale and upgrade policies, how to choose a setting that fits your lifestyle, and why seeing a diamond in person can matter more than the grading report alone. We also cover buying for yourself, traveling with valuable jewelry, and a few expensive mistakes buyers make when they don’t know which questions to ask. 

This is Part 1 of Buying Fine Jewelry because, as with watches, there was too much to cover in one conversation. In Part 2, we’ll cover buying jewelry online, metals, and why a relationship with a jeweler can matter more than you might think.

To contact Blue Water Jewelers, click here.

Holly Bohn Pittman

Holly Bohn Pittman is the founder of What I Expected. She previously founded See Jane Work, sold exclusively at Office Depot, and developed products for major retailers including Target, Walmart, Staples, Costco, and Sam's Club. A former CEO and CMO, she now tests what brands promise against what women 40+ actually experience, and rates each one MISS, MEET, or EXCEED.

Previous
Previous

EP05 The What I Expected Story: Part 1

Next
Next

EP03 Hair After 40: Part 1